AI chatbots are becoming the first doorway to news for a growing share of people. The paper cites a 2026 Reuters Institute survey finding that 10% of people across 48 countries now use AI chatbots for news, up from 7% the year before, with 16% of under-35s reporting the same. In the Global South, Latin America accounts for 14% of global traffic to AI platforms, making it the third-largest market by consumer presence.

The question this raises is simple: when the entry point changes from a list of links to a single paragraph, does the reader end up seeing more sources or fewer? A paper from the Oxford Internet Institute, posted on arXiv on 19 November by Francisco W. Kerche, Franziska Sofia Hafner, Felix M. Simon and Luc Rocher, gives a counterintuitive answer: fewer.

The scale of the experiment is not small. The team pulled 1,901 current events involving nine Latin American countries from the GDELT database, had a model write eight candidate conversational queries with different openings before picking one at random, translated it into the local language, and submitted it to three search engines (Google, Bing, Yahoo) and four web-search-enabled language models. That produced 49,207 requests across 8,834 unique domains.

Search engines were already narrow; the models stack another layer on top

Data cited by the paper shows the local-source share on each Google News country homepage: 88.9% for Brazil, 78.3% for Mexico and 63% for Colombia. More than 78% of global domains are registered in the United States and Europe.

The paper's own measurements are more direct. Within a single country, local users receive on average 42 fewer effective news outlets than foreign users, and the gap is wider for Google at 55.6 fewer. Across countries, only Google still shows that pattern: 76.5 effective outlets for locals against 124 for foreigners, while Bing and Yahoo vary much less across conditions.

On top of that, the language-model layer narrows things further. The paper finds that GPT-4o and Perplexity Sonar return fewer effective news outlets than search engines regardless of user conditions. For local users, the three search engines come in at Google 24.3, Bing 53.6 and Yahoo 44.9, while the four models come in at Claude 29.2, Grok 42.3, Perplexity 18.4 and GPT-4o 16.1. The gap widens in the across-countries comparison: GPT-4o at 33.9 and Perplexity at 46.9, against Google 76.5, Yahoo 142.5 and Bing 156.2. For local-language queries, the paper says GPT-4o and Perplexity fall below the search engines, Grok comes out above them, and Claude shows mixed results.

Local users get even less domestic news on top of that

Beyond diversity, the paper also measures the share of domestic sources. When local users search in their own language, search engines already return only 41.3% local news, and language models return a further 3.6 to 11.6 percentage points less. Broken down by model, GPT-4o gives up 3.58 points, Perplexity 11.6 points, Claude 9.2 points and Grok 9.5 points.

But there is a reversal here that headline framing tends to bury: not everyone is worse off. In the tourist scenario, GPT-4o's domestic share comes in 5.9 points above the search-engine average, and in the foreign-user scenario GPT-4o is 3.4 points above and Perplexity 1.8 points above. The paper's conclusion is that the effect depends on both the model and the user type, not that AI search is uniformly worse. Separately, when the comparison is made against Google alone, only GPT-4o fails to show a significant reduction.

Countries also differ. The paper reports that among the nine countries, only Brazil and Argentina have an average domestic news share above 50% for all language models and search engines, and that this share generally tracks the number of ccTLD domains registered in the country.

The mechanism has been measured before by other teams

That language models carry geographic bias is not a new observation. A paper by Manvi and colleagues at ICML 2024 (https://proceedings.mlr.press/v235/manvi24a.html) reached a similar conclusion: zero-shot geographic predictions correlate with ground truth at Spearman's rho up to 0.89, but on subjective topics such as attractiveness, morality and intelligence, the bias against locations with weaker socioeconomic conditions reaches rho up to 0.70. Another paper, Global-Liar (https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.17839), evaluated GPT models on a dataset balanced across geography and time and found the models privilege statements from the Global North over the Global South, with Africa and the Middle East at a clear disadvantage and much lower factual accuracy.

What this paper adds is not the observation that models are biased, but the relocation of that bias to the retrieval layer. The issue is not how a model describes a country, but that certain countries' reporting never becomes visible to you at all.

The supply side is moving too. Research by Zhao and Berman (https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.24968) uses a difference-in-differences approach and finds that large publishers who block generative AI crawlers via robots.txt see reduced website traffic compared to those who do not, while shifting toward richer content that is harder for LLMs to replicate. Connected to the above, when AI becomes the main doorway, the first response from publishers is to close the door, and once it is closed, who gets shut out becomes a structural question.

The cold water

The paper's own limitations deserve to be quoted directly. It states plainly that its findings may not generalise beyond the nine Latin American countries presented, because media landscapes and government control differ. More importantly, all interactions were single-shot with no user history and no personalisation, even though search engines adapt rankings and models increasingly add memory mechanisms that learn preferences across days and weeks. None of those long-horizon, user-specific effects were measured.

The method chain also carries a layer of model dependency: events come from GDELT, queries are generated and translated by gpt-4o-mini, and domain classification uses Cloudflare's content taxonomy, applied by a model as well. The four systems under test do not share a knowledge cutoff. Grok 3 runs from November 2024 to February 2025, GPT-4o mini is at October 2023, Claude 3.5 Haiku is at July 2024 and Perplexity does not publish one. The paper says events were chosen to fall outside those cutoffs, but the four systems still face different retrieval baselines.

So what

Latin America is someone else's test ground for Chinese readers, but the mechanism is general: what you see as local news is now decided by a selection process you cannot observe, and that process is neither broader than the search engine's nor better at knowing you. For teams building retrieval and aggregation systems, the paper also ships an open dataset, and the GDELT plus DataForSEO combination pushes the cost of reproducing the audit down to a marginal level. The question worth asking is not whether AI replaces search, but who decides the part you cannot see.